Comments on: One of Us, One of Them Review http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/ Ordinary people discovers, extraordinary things about themselves. They become HEROES Mon, 15 Mar 2010 23:13:41 -0700 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.5 hourly 1 By: herogirl http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47983 herogirl Sun, 05 Oct 2008 07:35:57 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47983 Those are all good p[oints but i think i mite be abl to splain some of it 1. Dl and niki were in a crowded hall way, if Dl phased it would hit someone behind him, AND someone would have seen what he could the secret would be out. 2.Theres something weird and pretty annoying abou linderman, but nathen is hullusinatin him because on some leval he believes every thins gon up in flames he wants som guidence. 3. i think that hiro can change everythin but he doesn't want to mess up the space/time continuum1 hes not that stupid 4.She was scared, and if abilitys really are in the brain, then the fear might have paralyed her power 5. that i can't explain, even though i did read somewhere that she was being controlled by someone named doyle 6.not sure about that one but it might have been a bit suss 7.Yeah powers have levels... whats wron with dat? it just that if two people wid da same power face off, it won't be a totally equal battle 8.in collision future hiro froze time and gave him the save the cheerleader same the world... or was it don't look back? well one of those, and then it crossed over to odessa and that wasn't frozen i think that ability varys as to what the user wants. 9.i think that west just enjoys flying more slower or normaly so he can do fun things like flips and dive through clouds. 10. i wopuld like to see more of them too, we might see more patience random fan... patience and i think that this is the best sow on tv!!!!!!!!!!! Those are all good p[oints but i think i mite be abl to splain some of it

1. Dl and niki were in a crowded hall way, if Dl phased it would hit someone behind him, AND someone would have seen what he could the secret would be out.

2.Theres something weird and pretty annoying abou linderman, but nathen is hullusinatin him because on some leval he believes every thins gon up in flames he wants som guidence.

3. i think that hiro can change everythin but he doesn’t want to mess up the space/time continuum1 hes not that stupid

4.She was scared, and if abilitys really are in the brain, then the fear might have paralyed her power

5. that i can’t explain, even though i did read somewhere that she was being controlled by someone named doyle

6.not sure about that one but it might have been a bit suss

7.Yeah powers have levels… whats wron with dat? it just that if two people wid da same power face off, it won’t be a totally equal battle

8.in collision future hiro froze time and gave him the save the cheerleader same the world… or was it don’t look back? well one of those, and then it crossed over to odessa and that wasn’t frozen i think that ability varys as to what the user wants.

9.i think that west just enjoys flying more slower or normaly so he can do fun things like flips and dive through clouds.

10. i wopuld like to see more of them too, we might see more patience random fan… patience

and i think that this is the best sow on tv!!!!!!!!!!!

]]> By: random fan part 2 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47968 random fan part 2 Sat, 04 Oct 2008 04:55:25 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47968 Furthermore, phew that was long - did u guys wonder how stupid DL died, he shoudl just hold on to niki both of them and use his ability then the bullet will jsut go through all of them, he CAn use his ability on many ppl he did that before - the linderman in brain... please... can we not have psycho ass bitcchhhh again? his power was like uggh.. okaii so ur kinda like claire but kinda like sylar - Hiro's time ability is appeared as super weak, i mean... he can control time, he can FIX everything or change everything. - elle's story is getting lame because her power is lgihging and when she was strangled by sylar she couldn't use it... should it be more automatic? - when claire was suffocating in the huge box... the mom was like.. loolalalalalal. i am so fine... - villains are so dumb compare to sylar... and by the way, its not his personal ability that he can get people's power, he knows if they have it or not, but he said it whilecutting claire's brain, a lot stuff that indicated that everyone can do the same... so 2nd sylar?... please? - So far we know that power has levels, like how Matt discover he can control people... soo in the future can claire just cure ppl, can tracy freeze the world.. - DAPHNE asked a really good question about hiro's power, if u freeeze time in japan does it change in AMERICA etc., question. yeah cuz if its true hiro is getting "younger" while claire and peter is getting "older" and DO U FEEEL time being freezed? cuz i mean DAPHNE DOES NOT run at the spped of light so wen hiro stopped time she should HAVE STOPPED COMPLETELY. -Nathan can fly etc., but his power is different from claire's ex. so is itjust ROCKET kinda way? - how come there is so many villans on show, but we never see the officers from the company i know elle, is but how come we dunt HAVE LIKE MOREEE? a lot more, and non of them really play as a main roll (i want the specials not NOAH) - and theres more... but i cna't think of it. btw ppl dun give crap like they are not perfect, i should just not watch it. cuz this isjust suggestion, THEY MADE a show superheroes, so be serious about it then. Furthermore, phew that was long
- did u guys wonder how stupid DL died, he shoudl just hold on to niki both of them and use his ability then the bullet will jsut go through all of them, he CAn use his ability on many ppl he did that before
- the linderman in brain… please… can we not have psycho ass bitcchhhh again? his power was like uggh.. okaii so ur kinda like claire but kinda like sylar
- Hiro’s time ability is appeared as super weak, i mean… he can control time, he can FIX everything or change everything.
- elle’s story is getting lame because her power is lgihging and when she was strangled by sylar she couldn’t use it… should it be more automatic?
- when claire was suffocating in the huge box… the mom was like.. loolalalalalal. i am so fine…
- villains are so dumb compare to sylar… and by the way, its not his personal ability that he can get people’s power, he knows if they have it or not, but he said it whilecutting claire’s brain, a lot stuff that indicated that everyone can do the same… so 2nd sylar?… please?
- So far we know that power has levels, like how Matt discover he can control people… soo in the future can claire just cure ppl, can tracy freeze the world..
- DAPHNE asked a really good question about hiro’s power, if u freeeze time in japan does it change in AMERICA etc., question. yeah cuz if its true hiro is getting “younger” while claire and peter is getting “older” and DO U FEEEL time being freezed? cuz i mean DAPHNE DOES NOT run at the spped of light so wen hiro stopped time she should HAVE STOPPED COMPLETELY.
-Nathan can fly etc., but his power is different from claire’s ex. so is itjust ROCKET kinda way?
- how come there is so many villans on show, but we never see the officers from the company i know elle, is but how come we dunt HAVE LIKE MOREEE? a lot more, and non of them really play as a main roll (i want the specials not NOAH)
- and theres more… but i cna’t think of it.
btw ppl dun give crap like they are not perfect, i should just not watch it.
cuz this isjust suggestion, THEY MADE a show superheroes, so be serious about it then.

]]> By: Random fan http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47967 Random fan Sat, 04 Oct 2008 04:33:34 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47967 okaii i love heroes etc., but i really think this is horrible season just list a few mistakes there and tehre: -future peter comes back to present day mess around the world, COMPLETELY nothing changed about him, his powers should atleast be somehow different, - in season 1 we saw niki in the future and she was dating peter, but niki died, so how did peter and claire meet? aren't they uncle and niece, kinda gross huh? "i always loved you" - what happened to the coolest abilitiy? like monica, the girl who can copy physical movement - and whoeever typed the thing about sylar being super strong, i totally agree with you its super stupid, sylar is unbeatable. - in this episode we see claire almost dying from suffocation so she can die, and adam monroe should have suffocate in the coffin by now, but no he is alive becuz we see and angela's dream he will team with niki/tracy (traki) - what was the power that future peter used to pur present peter in people's body? - If any of you remembered in season 1 the crazy murder (when we were introduced with sylar) killed a man with freezing ability... yeah... so sylar should have that power too, but like always the cast never mention it. - so sylar doesn't eat the brain, he puts his finger in it and feel an orgy, and go 'oooohh i got it' - in episode 2 it was so fake when he turned the gun to gold... it looked the same weight when he spins it. - the cutting ability sylar has, the bzzzz on forehead, is that a power or part of teleknsis - haitian, after getting knocked out could not use his ability which mean- sylar can just knock him and still perform his bzzz. And no one knows the distance of Haitian ability, do we have to be close... or what? and if my power is fire and throw fire at him does it disappear or does it still work. -HALO? what happened to the writers. where is our damn cool abilities as in creative ones? i mean evrything we see is repeptive, isaac's paitning, elle' blue lighting becomes ando's red, adam= claire. there was super cool ablities before, like my FAV the persuation girl : ) yeah totally disppointed with heroes, wat happened? okaii i love heroes etc.,
but i really think this is horrible season
just list a few mistakes there and tehre:
-future peter comes back to present day mess around the world, COMPLETELY nothing changed about him, his powers should atleast be somehow different,
- in season 1 we saw niki in the future and she was dating peter, but niki died, so how did peter and claire meet? aren’t they uncle and niece, kinda gross huh? “i always loved you”
- what happened to the coolest abilitiy? like monica, the girl who can copy physical movement
- and whoeever typed the thing about sylar being super strong, i totally agree with you its super stupid, sylar is unbeatable.
- in this episode we see claire almost dying from suffocation so she can die, and adam monroe should have suffocate in the coffin by now, but no he is alive becuz we see and angela’s dream he will team with niki/tracy (traki)
- what was the power that future peter used to pur present peter in people’s body?
- If any of you remembered in season 1 the crazy murder (when we were introduced with sylar) killed a man with freezing ability… yeah… so sylar should have that power too, but like always the cast never mention it.
- so sylar doesn’t eat the brain, he puts his finger in it and feel an orgy, and go ‘oooohh i got it’
- in episode 2 it was so fake when he turned the gun to gold… it looked the same weight when he spins it.
- the cutting ability sylar has, the bzzzz on forehead, is that a power or part of teleknsis
- haitian, after getting knocked out could not use his ability which mean- sylar can just knock him and still perform his bzzz. And no one knows the distance of Haitian ability, do we have to be close… or what? and if my power is fire and throw fire at him does it disappear or does it still work.
-HALO? what happened to the writers. where is our damn cool abilities as in creative ones? i mean evrything we see is repeptive, isaac’s paitning, elle’ blue lighting becomes ando’s red, adam= claire. there was super cool ablities before, like my FAV the persuation girl : )
yeah totally disppointed with heroes, wat happened?

]]> By: mega-O http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47948 mega-O Fri, 03 Oct 2008 06:08:39 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47948 yeah... i think that there are scenes or infos from season 2 that were already forgotten [like the scene where claire regenerated a toe and the powers that sylar took (i mean he could use again all those powers, i'm tired of the head-slashing thing)]... 'heroes' is ..... oh well yeah… i think that there are scenes or infos from season 2 that were already forgotten [like the scene where claire regenerated a toe and the powers that sylar took (i mean he could use again all those powers, i'm tired of the head-slashing thing)]…

‘heroes’ is ….. oh well

]]> By: ffilou6 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47923 ffilou6 Thu, 02 Oct 2008 10:41:17 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47923 Sylar said Claire can't die. But in a dream of Mama Petrelli, Claire was beheaded. Did she die? Or is her head still alive, and may take a loonngg time to make a new body like lizard when she cut her little toe? Or waiting to be connected to her body or someone's else beheaded body? Sylar said Claire can’t die. But in a dream of Mama Petrelli, Claire was beheaded. Did she die? Or is her head still alive, and may take a loonngg time to make a new body like lizard when she cut her little toe? Or waiting to be connected to her body or someone’s else beheaded body?

]]> By: CKH http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47908 CKH Thu, 02 Oct 2008 03:43:33 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47908 haha, agreed, the bad guy part is really cheesy haha, agreed, the bad guy part is really cheesy

]]> By: ali http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47897 ali Wed, 01 Oct 2008 11:58:41 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47897 im obsessed with heroes, to such an extent that i forgive every plot hole and mistake that comes along the way. The scene with claire and her mom was by far the worst and cheesiest scene i have witnessed on television... 'why do you wanna catch bad guys?' .. bad guys ?? wtf !! Not only do humans have powers, the walkman in africa apparently has powers too... this volume is starting to freak me out, so far everything that has worked in this volume has been a cheap shot... a quick fix at giving people what they want to see. however saying all of that, i think this episode, barring the scenes with claire, was amazing. The villains were cool... tragedy that two of them are already dead without any story whatsoever.. but that entire scene was cool and i was waiting for sylar to kick some villains in the face. The promo for the next episode looks like gossip girl... for gods sake, are writers completely forgetting that sylar is one evil mofo. I'm still really interested as to how they'll do this whole zimmmerman thing, if suresh will become the hulk, gollum or some twisted freak, and when peter will wake up and realise he's also on this show. Please dont ruin this show. it has the potential to be the next starwars, however it looks like its gonna resemble the matrix trilogy. Sylar needs to be badass, not everyone needs to be related, claire's mother needs to learn how to act, the writers need to come up with cooler lines than 'bad guys'. im obsessed with heroes, to such an extent that i forgive every plot hole and mistake that comes along the way. The scene with claire and her mom was by far the worst and cheesiest scene i have witnessed on television… ‘why do you wanna catch bad guys?’ .. bad guys ?? wtf !! Not only do humans have powers, the walkman in africa apparently has powers too…

this volume is starting to freak me out, so far everything that has worked in this volume has been a cheap shot… a quick fix at giving people what they want to see.

however saying all of that, i think this episode, barring the scenes with claire, was amazing. The villains were cool… tragedy that two of them are already dead without any story whatsoever.. but that entire scene was cool and i was waiting for sylar to kick some villains in the face. The promo for the next episode looks like gossip girl… for gods sake, are writers completely forgetting that sylar is one evil mofo. I’m still really interested as to how they’ll do this whole zimmmerman thing, if suresh will become the hulk, gollum or some twisted freak, and when peter will wake up and realise he’s also on this show.

Please dont ruin this show. it has the potential to be the next starwars, however it looks like its gonna resemble the matrix trilogy.

Sylar needs to be badass, not everyone needs to be related, claire’s mother needs to learn how to act, the writers need to come up with cooler lines than ‘bad guys’.

]]> By: GizDD http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47895 GizDD Wed, 01 Oct 2008 10:02:39 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47895 We still have 8 villans to meet too don't we? There were 12 in level 5? I hope they bring the guy from the webisodes in, though his power seems to be the same as jesse's. I can't believe they killed off francis capra so quick. I also think there's at least another nikki clone, the doctor called tracy a different name when she came to his door. We still have 8 villans to meet too don’t we? There were 12 in level 5? I hope they bring the guy from the webisodes in, though his power seems to be the same as jesse’s. I can’t believe they killed off francis capra so quick.

I also think there’s at least another nikki clone, the doctor called tracy a different name when she came to his door.

]]> By: kohaxx http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47887 kohaxx Wed, 01 Oct 2008 01:04:11 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47887 That's how I felt too MasterMind, the villains seemed like one trick ponies. The main difference is that Sylar doesn't run around killing non-specials and doesn't try to attract attention. However I'm with HRG: "So to catch the psychopaths you let loose a monster?" The feeding thing didn't make any sense, surely there was someone evil they could feed him instead, that and there wasn't any benefit to gaining that girl's power. I guess it was an attempt to gain his trust, they'll be feeding him so he shouldn't run off, which he very easily could have after the bank. That’s how I felt too MasterMind, the villains seemed like one trick ponies. The main difference is that Sylar doesn’t run around killing non-specials and doesn’t try to attract attention.

However I’m with HRG: “So to catch the psychopaths you let loose a monster?”

The feeding thing didn’t make any sense, surely there was someone evil they could feed him instead, that and there wasn’t any benefit to gaining that girl’s power. I guess it was an attempt to gain his trust, they’ll be feeding him so he shouldn’t run off, which he very easily could have after the bank.

]]> By: MasterMind http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47886 MasterMind Wed, 01 Oct 2008 00:51:59 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47886 Kohaxx: Thanks. It seemed a little ambiguous to me. So... is it me, or did the Level 5 villains totally suck? I had a feeling that would happen. I was like, how could Sylar who has like a million abilities be level 2 and they be level 5? Then the bank scene confirmed my suspicion that Sylar would completely wipe the floor with them. It wasn't even freaking necessary for Angela to "feed" him. After all the hype about the escape from level 5, it seems like their only problem is still Sylar. Kohaxx: Thanks. It seemed a little ambiguous to me.

So… is it me, or did the Level 5 villains totally suck? I had a feeling that would happen. I was like, how could Sylar who has like a million abilities be level 2 and they be level 5? Then the bank scene confirmed my suspicion that Sylar would completely wipe the floor with them. It wasn’t even freaking necessary for Angela to “feed” him.

After all the hype about the escape from level 5, it seems like their only problem is still Sylar.

]]> By: CorrosionX http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47885 CorrosionX Wed, 01 Oct 2008 00:35:53 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47885 To the author: I don't want to be the grammar police, but you seriously need to re-read yourself. I don't know if English is your main language but there's a lot of mistakes in there... To the author:

I don’t want to be the grammar police, but you seriously need to re-read yourself. I don’t know if English is your main language but there’s a lot of mistakes in there…

]]> By: HolidayKid http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47879 HolidayKid Tue, 30 Sep 2008 18:50:45 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47879 Claire is turning into Adam slowly but shortly Claire is turning into Adam slowly but shortly

]]> By: Kohaxx http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47877 Kohaxx Tue, 30 Sep 2008 17:55:57 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47877 Pieper: Yeah I think she just wants to feel significant, she's been neither here nor there so far, not really accomplishing anything. Although hopefully she can be saved from becoming cold depressed future Claire. MasterMind: Yeah, the splatter of blood indicates he's dead. Man I got the weirdest vibe from Angela/Sylar I swear it was like she was going to reach over and pinch his cheeks and say "Who's a good boy" at any moment. /shiver Pieper: Yeah I think she just wants to feel significant, she’s been neither here nor there so far, not really accomplishing anything. Although hopefully she can be saved from becoming cold depressed future Claire.

MasterMind: Yeah, the splatter of blood indicates he’s dead.

Man I got the weirdest vibe from Angela/Sylar I swear it was like she was going to reach over and pinch his cheeks and say “Who’s a good boy” at any moment.

/shiver

]]> By: MasterMind http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47875 MasterMind Tue, 30 Sep 2008 17:15:59 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47875 So did Sylar kill Jesse? So did Sylar kill Jesse?

]]> By: Pieper http://www.heroesrevealed.com/episode-review/one-of-us-one-of-them-review/comment-page-1/#comment-47873 Pieper Tue, 30 Sep 2008 16:47:18 +0000 http://www.heroesrevealed.com/?p=1621#comment-47873 Claire doesnt want to hurt sylar, she wants to hurt everybody who is special , some sort of. Not only Sylar! Claire doesnt want to hurt sylar, she wants to hurt everybody who is special , some sort of. Not only Sylar!

]]>