Andyb says:

Lol Acerman, think out side the box.

if he can time travel it dont matter if he can do it now or in 20 years, he can go back to that point and push Kaito off the roof.

but just a theory…

oh yeah the Nightmare man is gonna be a bit like nightmare on elm street / freddy vs jason – attack you in your dreams and your injuries show in real life. – dunno if i like that idea in heroes. hope i’m wrong

J says:

If you look at the height of the person who killed Hero’s dad, it has to be someone who is skinny, around 5′8-9 and male (look at his hands, those are not females.) So i deduce it is Peter. Who else can it be? The preview says “it is one of them.” Cant be claude, too tall, DL is dead and black, Parkmen is fat, Hero is small and fat, Jesse/Nicci, could be, but the killer doest walk the same as her, so who is left? Syler? Killer too small. So it has to be Peter. The killer has the same Body Language at Peter, same height 5′10, white, male hands, and if you look at when Milo in jeans, it is similar to the killer, who is also wearing jeans, same mold and same shape of legs. From taht, i say its peter.

-j

sandy says:

Did any of you think that it could be West(Claire’s boyfriend). He cn fly as well and he is hiding something. He was to aggressive about Clarie’s power sneaking to her house watching her. Maybe he is the child of one of the 12 in the photo. Also he remembers HRG and the picture that showed HRG dead maybe that was West with clarie. Maybe West wants payback. Just a thought. Spoiler: West finds out that HRG is Clarie’s dad(Ummmmmmmm).

Asfand says:

You guys all wrong its papa petrelli, because everyone thought that he is dead but may be just may be he isnt dead and now he is taking revenge on all of his old friends, and besdie tim did not mentioned what power peter and nathan dad did posssed.

catastrophe says:

Does anyone think that DL’s Mother, Paulette Hawkins, is actually one of the 12 in the group, the one sitting on the most left of the front row?

http://heroeswiki.com/Image:Unnamed_woman_3.jpg

http://heroeswiki.com/Image:MrsHawkins.jpg

Are they the same person??

guest says:

it`s nathan!!!!!! 100% true!!! believe this!!! he is it, or more it`s his evil side. he suffers the same illness as did jessica/nikki. The schizophrenic appearences in the mirrors are the hint to the solution… good way to incoorparate him into the storyline.

Kevin says:

If the preview of “it’s one of them” means that it’s a character from Season 1, (Nathan, Peter, Hiro, etc…) versus this season of “Generations”, then my pure guess is that it’s Nathan Petrelli [his evil side, the "monster"]. Nathan is trying to escape his past or something. However, I really think that the killer is “one of them” referring to the group of 12. The original generations. I really think that it’s the unidentified character from the far right side of the photo. The guy sitting in front of Parkman’s father. He looks like a guy the same height and as menacing. I’m always wrong on these things so I’ll probably be wrong again.